1997年，A.C.推出了他们最受瞩目的专辑《I Like It When You Die》，关于这张唱片的评价处于前所未有的对立状态，互联网上的评分只有两种结果：0分或者100分。赞扬者们高呼：“这简直就是新圣经！”、“浪漫的鲜血与雷电的伟大结合体！”、“超级喜剧时刻！”、“灵魂的通便药！”、“有史以来最酷乐队！”等等。著名的《Village Voice》杂志专属评论家安·马洛称A.C.“应该会变得著名”，前Minuteman乐队贝司手迈克·瓦特也毫不掩饰自己对于A.C.的专辑《I Like It When You Die》的喜爱，并说他经常在自己的互联网电台上播放这些歌。（不过乐队主唱Putnam后来告诉瓦特说他曾有一首歌叫作“互联网是同性恋”。）反对者们则更直接：“零分！”、“恶心！”、“世界最差乐队！”、“难以相信这样的垃圾竟然可以全国发行！”等等。
Break out the tissues, because America's going to cry. Or laugh really hard, if you happen to be in on the inanely offensive joke that A.C. has ridden to perverse perfection. A.C. -- whose sound might best be described as metal's response to dysentery -- stretched shock value to its most absurd limits on such albums as Morbid Florist and 40 More Reasons to Hate Us. I Like It When You Die (1997) follows in an all too similar vein. As with all things A.C., the humor's in the context, the proportions, and, of course, the song titles. I Like It When You Die weighs in at an epic 52 songs, but few exceed 60 seconds in length. Each song sputters forth with blast beats, gravel-crunch guitars, indecipherable, cat-in-a-blender vocals, and abrupt endings. Call it musical premature ejaculation, call it total swill, but above all else, A.C. is only trying to be funny. So laugh if you want. Die delivers its punch lines with dimwitted condescension, and reading the album's track list is like watching The Onion, grindcore parody, and Beavis and Butthead all meet each other halfway. The album boasts song titles like